Blog

Selecting the right approach to bathroom amenities might seem like a small detail, but it shapes your guests’ experience, your brand identity, and your bottom line. For hosts managing multiple properties, the choice between travel-size bottles and refillable dispensers is more than an operational preference—it’s a signal of what you value as a host.

This guide explores the costs, guest expectations, and sustainability impacts of each option. You’ll also discover trends shaping the future of short-term rental amenities and practical tips for making the best choice for your business.

Financial Considerations: Upfront Costs vs. Long-Term Savings

When comparing travel-size bottles to refillable dispensers, it’s easy to focus on initial price tags. But a deeper look at total costs over time often tells a more compelling story.

Initial Investment

Travel-size toiletries have a low barrier to entry, typically costing about $0.50 per unit when bought in bulk. This means a starter set of shampoo, conditioner, and body wash can cost as little as $1.50 per bathroom.

By contrast, refillable dispensers require a higher upfront investment—around $15 per dispenser or $45 for a three-product setup. Though this may seem steep, the breakeven point arrives surprisingly quickly.

Refill Costs Over Time

Single-use bottles must be replaced after each guest, costing approximately $1.50 per stay per product. If your property hosts 100 guests per year, that adds up to $450 annually just to restock three products.

Refillable dispensers, however, rely on bulk refills at roughly $0.30 per product per month. Even factoring in cleaning and occasional pump replacement, the annual refill cost typically stays below $108.

Tip: For many hosts, the savings become apparent after just a few months of operation, particularly for high-occupancy rentals.

Annual Cost Comparison (Illustrative Example)

Guest Experience: Familiar Luxury vs. Contemporary Convenience

While cost matters, guests’ perceptions often have an even greater impact on your success. Thoughtfully chosen toiletries send a message about your commitment to comfort and care.

Perceived Value

Individually packaged products evoke a sense of familiarity and indulgence, especially when they feature recognizable brands. For many travelers, these amenities feel like an expected hallmark of hotel-quality stays.

By contrast, refillable dispensers create a clean, modern look that appeals to guests who appreciate simplicity and sustainability. High-quality dispensers crafted from stainless steel, glass, or matte finishes can feel every bit as premium, just in a different way.

Convenience and Functionality

Travel-size bottles have the advantage of portability—guests can take them on outings or keep them by the sink. However, they can also create clutter on counters and run out during longer stays.

Refillable dispensers provide a clutter-free presentation and reliable supply. Many feature smooth pump mechanisms, clear viewing windows, and tamper-resistant designs that reassure guests about hygiene.

Tip: If you use dispensers, consider leaving a small explanatory card to highlight their hygienic maintenance and environmental benefits.

New Trends: Accessibility, Branding, and Regulations

Accessibility and Ease of Use

For guests with limited mobility or arthritis, large pump dispensers can be easier to use than twisting small caps. If accessibility is a priority for your property, consider ADA-compliant designs with ergonomic pumps.

Custom Branding

More hosts are customizing dispensers with their property’s name or logo. This creates a cohesive, professional look that reinforces your brand and provides a memorable touch.

Regulatory Changes

Several states and countries are moving to ban single-use plastic toiletry bottles in hospitality settings. California, for example, has enacted legislation restricting them in hotels. Transitioning to dispensers now helps you future-proof your property.

Sustainability Considerations

Travel-size bottles remain a familiar favorite but come with a significant environmental footprint. According to research, small bottles generate almost 981 tons of plastic waste annually, much of which ends up in landfills.

Fortunately, hospitality brands are making impactful changes. Major hotel groups like Marriott International have transitioned to wall-mounted refillable dispensers, eliminating up to 500 million mini bottles per year—the equivalent of 1.7 million pounds of plastic. Similarly, properties like Hotel Verde in California have reduced in-room plastic waste by approximately 80% in a single year by implementing refillable systems.

Alternative Packaging Options:

• Solid toiletry bars with minimal packaging
• Aluminum bottles that can be infinitely recycled
• Biodegradable containers made from sugar cane or wheat straw

Maintenance and Housekeeping

Restocking Frequency

Travel-size toiletries must be replaced after each stay, requiring consistent inventory management. For busy seasons, this means higher time and labor demands.

Refillable dispensers typically need refilling weekly, though you’ll want to clean nozzles and check levels between guests. While bulk refills can be a bit messier, many hosts report the process becomes routine over time.

Cleaning Protocols

• Travel-size bottles: Little cleaning needed, but more frequent replacement
• Refillable dispensers: Monthly sanitizing recommended and a wipe-down between guests

Tip: Develop a simple checklist to train your cleaning team on proper refilling and sanitation. (add link to cleaning checklist)

Where to Source Quality Amenities

When it comes to elevating your guest experience while maintaining visual consistency and sustainability, choosing the right supplier matters. Whether you're furnishing a boutique hotel, a short-term rental, or a luxury property, Amenie is your go-to destination for premium, eco-conscious amenities designed for the modern traveler.

Recommended Dispenser Systems

• SOLera: Elegant, minimalist designs built for durability and ease of use.
• Aquamenities: Luxury-grade, wall-mounted dispensers designed to meet LEED and ADA compliance standards—ideal for eco-forward hospitality brands.
• Aquavera: Sleek, European-inspired dispensers offering a modern look with practical refill systems.

Making Your Decision

Ultimately, there is no universal answer. The best approach balances:

• Guest expectations
• Sustainability goals
• Operational realities
• Your property’s aesthetic

A Quick Checklist to Guide Your Choice:

1. What matters most to your guests—familiarity or modern minimalism?
2. Are you prepared to invest in dispensers for long-term savings?
3. Will your cleaning routine adapt easily to bulk refills?
4. Do you want to highlight your property’s commitment to sustainability?
5. Are you operating in a region moving toward plastic bans?

Making the Right Choice for Your Property

Thoughtful amenities transform routine stays into memorable experiences. Whether you opt for travel-size bottles or sleek refillable dispensers, choose products that reflect your brand values and serve your guests with care.

By considering all factors—costs, guest impressions, environmental impact, and practicality—you’ll build a hosting strategy that supports your success in 2025 and beyond.